Books like I Kissed Shara Wheeler

I Kissed Shara Wheeler by Casey McQuiston reads as witty, emotional. These 12 books share its genome — matched by how they actually read, not just their shelf label.

Love, Creekwood

Becky Albertalli · 2020

Same ya feel

64% genome match

Red, White & Royal Blue

Casey McQuiston · 2019

Both explore rivalry

83% genome match

Check & Mate

Ali Hazelwood · 2023

Both explore rivalry

78% genome match

Cemetery Boys

Aiden Thomas

Same ya feel

60% genome match

The Spanish Love Deception

Elena Armas · 2021

Both explore rivalry

73% genome match

The Viscount Who Loved Me

Julia Quinn · 2000

Both explore rivalry

73% genome match

Things We Never Got Over

Lucy Score · 2020

Both explore small town

72% genome match

Juliet takes a breath

Gabby Rivera · 2016

Same ya feel

59% genome match

Jack of Hearts (and other parts)

L. C. Rosen · 2018

Same ya feel

62% genome match

Boy Meets Boy

David Levithan · 2003

Same ya feel

58% genome match

It Happened One Summer

Tessa Bailey · 2021

Both explore small town

72% genome match

Better Than the Movies

Lynn Painter · 2021

Same romance feel

83% genome match