Books like If We Were Villains

If We Were Villains by M.L. Rio reads as dark, immersive. These 12 books share its genome — matched by how they actually read, not just their shelf label.

What If We Were Villains is like to read

A confession framed a decade after the fact, saturated in Shakespeare quotation and the claustrophobia of a small theater conservatory where art and rivalry curdle into something lethal. Elegiac, guilt-heavy, and structured like a five-act tragedy. Best for: readers who loved The Secret History and want dark-academia soaked in Shakespeare.

Bunny

Mona Awad · 2019

A hallucinatory campus satire that curdles from mean-girl mockery into body-horror surrealism, narrated by a lonely outsider whose grip on reality slips as she's drawn into the Bunnies' saccharine coven.

intensely scarycomplete storydeep cut

The Maidens

Alex Michaelides · 2021

A dark-academia thriller of obsession as a grieving therapist fixates on a charismatic professor she's sure is a killer, laced with Greek-tragedy motifs and Cambridge atmosphere.

creepy, not gorycomplete storydeep cut

The Witch Elm

Tana French · 2018

Shares the vhypno thread

Rebecca

Daphne du Maurier · 1938

A creeping, dread-soaked gothic in which a timid young bride is slowly suffocated by the ghost of her husband's first wife — atmospheric, jealousy-poisoned, and building to a genuinely shocking revelation.

intensely scarycomplete story

Catherine House

Elisabeth Thomas · 2020

An immersive, slow-building gothic mystery about isolation and institutional secrecy at an elite, cloistered school, driven more by atmosphere and dread than action.

creepy, not gorydeep cut

Haunting Adeline

H.D. Carlton · 2021

A deliberately transgressive dark-romance where a stalker's obsessive POV alternates with his target's, escalating from surveillance into explicit, violent, non-consensual territor

high heatintensely scarycliffhanger

Misery

Stephen King · 1987

A single-room nightmare of captivity and coerced creation — feverish, propulsive, and unbearably tense as the writer's typewriter becomes both weapon and lifeline.

intensely scarycomplete story

The Phantom of the Opera

Gaston Leroux · 1910

A melancholic, suspenseful gothic romance steeped in obsession and tragic passion, where a mysterious figure's feverish devotion to a young singer drives a narrative of isolation a

deep cut