Books like The Pumpkin Spice Cafe

The Pumpkin Spice Cafe by Laurie Gilmore reads as cozy, warm. These 12 books share its genome — matched by how they actually read, not just their shelf label.

The Cheat Sheet

Sarah Adams

Both explore love

67% genome match

Things We Never Got Over

Lucy Score · 2020

Both explore small town & love

83% genome match

Set on You

Amy Lea · 2022

Same romance feel

61% genome match

The Summer of Broken Rules

K. L. Walther · 2021

Both explore love

61% genome match

Part of Your World

Abby Jimenez · 2022

Both explore love & small town

83% genome match

It Happened One Summer

Tessa Bailey · 2021

Both explore small town & love

83% genome match

Meet Me at the Lake

Carley Fortune · 2023

Both explore love

61% genome match

The Fine Print

Lauren Asher · 2021

Same romance feel

56% genome match

The Seven Year Slip

Ashley Poston · 2023

Both explore love

55% genome match

Can You Keep A Secret?

Sophie Kinsella · 2003

Same romance feel

54% genome match

Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating

Christina Lauren · 2018

Same romance feel

56% genome match

People We Meet on Vacation

Emily Henry · 2021

Both explore love

55% genome match