Books like The Sicilian

The Sicilian by Mario Puzo reads as gritty, dramatic. These 12 books share its genome — matched by how they actually read, not just their shelf label.

What The Sicilian is like to read

A crime-saga companion to The Godfather that trades New York for post-war Sicily, following a legendary bandit caught between the Mafia, the state, and his own myth. Power, loyalty, and betrayal drive an epic, tragic-feeling arc. Best for: readers who loved The Godfather and want mafia intrigue rooted in Sicilian history.

The Godfather

Mario Puzo · 1969

An immersive plunge into the Corleone family's empire — patient, muscular storytelling that treats brutal power plays with the gravity of tragedy.

mildly eeriecomplete story

The friends of Eddie Coyle

George V. Higgins · 1972

Both explore loyalty

Safe Place

Lorenzo Carcaterra · 1993

A brooding tale of four friends scarred by a shared childhood trauma who band together as adults to enact brutal, personal justice on those who hurt them.

deep cut

When the Women Come Out to Dance

Elmore Leonard · 2002

A collection of tightly written crime stories showcasing Leonard's knack for vivid lowlifes, sharp banter, and sudden reversals of fortune among criminals and their marks.

deep cut

The Drop

Dennis Lehane · 2001

A taut crime thriller in which a quiet man's act of mercy—rescuing a pit bull—becomes the thread that unravels his constructed isolation and forces him into a web of organized violence and unresolved guilt.

deep cut

Guns

Evan Hunter · 1976

Both explore revenge

City of Dreams

Don Winslow · 2023

Both explore power & loyalty

The cartel 6

Ashley · 2016

A pulpy, high-body-count crime saga where Vegas glitz curdles into desert-grave betrayals — fast, brutal, and soap-operatic in its family-empire treacheries.

deep cut

Payback Is A Mutha

Wahida Clark · 2006

A hard-edged street saga where betrayal and loyalty collide, forcing characters to enact their own brutal brand of justice.

deep cut

Road to Perdition

Max Allan Collins · 1998

A noir-inflected thriller following a hitman and his son fleeing mob retribution, balancing visceral action and moral reckoning with intimate family dynamics and the cost of violence.

deep cut