Books like Overdue
Overdue by Richie Tankersley Cusick reads as suspenseful, creepy. These 12 books share its genome — matched by how they actually read, not just their shelf label.
What Overdue is like to read
A tight YA stalker-thriller built around a library and a menacing bookmark, leaning on suspect-shuffling and escalating threats rather than gore. Best for: readers who want a quick, atmospheric 90s teen slasher-in-print with a whodunit spine.
Fear Street Cheerleaders - The First Evil
Robert Lawrence Stine · 1992
A quick, propulsive teen slasher where cheerleading tryouts curdle into a body count — short chapters and chapter-end shocks keep the pages turning without demanding much of the reader.
The Thrill Club
R. L. Stine · 1994
A twisty teen horror premise where a writer's scary stories bleed into real victims — quick chapters, escalating suspicion, and a whodunit engine aimed squarely at YA readers.
Book of Horrors (Nightmare Hall, No 16)
Diane Hoh · 1994
Both explore secrets & revenge
Witch
Christopher Pike · 1990
A teen psychic thriller that blends visions, revenge, and small-town supernatural intrigue at a brisk clip, though the plotting piles coincidence on coincidence.
Locked in time
Lois Duncan · 1985
A teenage outsider senses something deeply wrong at her stepmother's Louisiana plantation, and the dread builds through small oddities into genuine menace.
Fetch (Five Nights at Freddy’s
Scott Cawthon · 2020
Three brisk horror novellas about kids grabbing for control of their lives and paying for it in the Fazbear universe — episodic, plot-forward, and built for quick scares rather than deep prose.
April fools
Richie Tankersley Cusick · 1991
A fast, guilt-driven YA horror ride where a hit-and-run cover-up unravels through escalating stalker pranks; propulsive chapters and mounting dread keep the pages turning.
Thirteen
T. Pines · 1991
A YA horror anthology of thirteen short shocks from genre-brand authors like Christopher Pike and R.
Ten
Gretchen McNeil · 2012
A fast, body-count-driven slasher mystery where isolated teens are picked off one by one, propelled by short chapters and constant suspicion.
The Twisted Ones
Kira Breed-Wrisley · 2017
A propulsive YA horror sequel that plunges a trauma-haunted heroine back into the animatronic nightmare — nightmares, fresh corpses, and a hunt that won't let go.
The Cheerleader
Caroline B. Cooney · 1991
A lonely girl's Faustian bargain for popularity curdles into something darker as her hunger outpaces the price she agreed to pay.
Doom Stone
Paul Zindel · 1995
Zindel applies his signature earnest teen voice and dark dramatic tone to horror territory, grounding supernatural terror in intimate teenage perspective as protagonists confront an unstoppable cursed force.
About Overdue — what the genome says
Is Overdue a complete story or a cliffhanger?
It's a complete, standalone-satisfying story.
How scary is Overdue?
Genuinely frightening — the genome rates its fear intensity high.
Who is Overdue for?
It's young adult — teen protagonists with crossover appeal.
Find your next read by its genome
Tell Novelome one book you love — get recommendations tuned to your taste, including the ones other sites never surface.
Start free →More readalikes: Books like THE LET THEM THEORY · Books like EXTREME OWNERSHIP · Books like WINGS OF STARLIGHT · Books like DON'T BELIEVE EVERYTHING YOU THINK, EXPANDED EDITION · Books like I WILL TEACH YOU TO BE RICH, SECOND EDITION · Books like FAKE SKATING · Books like THE CREATIVE ACT · Books like IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER