Books like Overdue

Overdue by Richie Tankersley Cusick reads as suspenseful, creepy. These 12 books share its genome — matched by how they actually read, not just their shelf label.

Fear Street Cheerleaders - The First Evil

Robert Lawrence Stine · 1992

Both explore curses & revenge

89% genome match

The Thrill Club

R. L. Stine · 1994

Both explore secrets

71% genome match

Book of Horrors (Nightmare Hall, No 16)

Diane Hoh · 1994

Both explore secrets & revenge

82% genome match

Witch

Christopher Pike · 1990

Both explore revenge & secrets

80% genome match

The third eye

Lois Duncan · 1984

Same ya feel

68% genome match

Fetch (Five Nights at Freddy’s

Scott Cawthon · 2020

Both explore revenge & supernatural

75% genome match

April fools

Richie Tankersley Cusick · 1991

Both explore revenge & secrets

77% genome match

Thirteen

T. Pines · 1991

Both explore supernatural

73% genome match

Ten

Gretchen McNeil · 2012

Both explore secrets

73% genome match

The Werewolf of Fever Swamp

R. L. Stine · 2009

Both explore secrets

66% genome match

Locked in time

Lois Duncan · 1985

Both explore secrets

66% genome match

Chain Letter 2. The Ancient Evil

Christopher Pike · 1992

Both explore revenge & secrets

80% genome match