Books like The Cheerleader
The Cheerleader by Caroline B. Cooney reads as eerie, suspenseful. These 12 books share its genome — matched by how they actually read, not just their shelf label.
What The Cheerleader is like to read
A lonely girl's Faustian bargain for popularity curdles into something darker as her hunger outpaces the price she agreed to pay. The pull is the moral slide, not the mystery. Best for: YA readers who want a dark bargain premise and a morally slippery protagonist.
Remember me 3
Christopher Pike · 1995
A supernatural YA thriller where a teen Wanderer's inspired writing becomes the very thing hunted by inhuman enemies — brisk, plainspoken, and steeped in Pike's blend of metaphysics and menace.
The Thrill Club
R. L. Stine · 1994
A twisty teen horror premise where a writer's scary stories bleed into real victims — quick chapters, escalating suspicion, and a whodunit engine aimed squarely at YA readers.
The Perfect Date
Robert Lawrence Stine · 1996
A teen horror-thriller where a boy's fresh romance curdles under the shadow of his dead girlfriend — short chapters and cliffhanger beats built for a fast weekend scare.
Nightmare Hall #4 The Wish
Diane Hoh · 1993
A quick, campy campus-horror read where wishes twist into curses—light on depth, heavy on twisty consequences and mounting dread among friends.
Fetch (Five Nights at Freddy’s
Scott Cawthon · 2020
Three brisk horror novellas about kids grabbing for control of their lives and paying for it in the Fazbear universe — episodic, plot-forward, and built for quick scares rather than deep prose.
Thirteen
T. Pines · 1991
A YA horror anthology of thirteen short shocks from genre-brand authors like Christopher Pike and R.
Overdue
Richie Tankersley Cusick · 1995
A tight YA stalker-thriller built around a library and a menacing bookmark, leaning on suspect-shuffling and escalating threats rather than gore.
Dare to be scared Thirteen Stories To Chill And Thrill
Robert D. San Souci · 2003
A campfire-style anthology of quick, spooky tales built for group reading and sleepovers — mild scares, folklore-inflected, meant to thrill without traumatizing.
Stranger with my face
Lois Duncan · 1981
A paranoid teen mystery about a girl who begins to suspect the double haunting her life may be more than imagination — unsettling in a quiet, domestic way rather than gory.
More Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
Alvin Schwartz · 1605
A quick, campfire-style collection of short creepy retellings — episodic scares aimed at younger readers, more unsettling than gory.
The Chase
Lisa Jane Smith · 1994
Both explore obsession & supernatural
Fate Totally Worse Than Death
Paul Fleischman · 1995
Both explore revenge & supernatural
About The Cheerleader — what the genome says
How scary is The Cheerleader?
Genuinely frightening — the genome rates its fear intensity high.
Who is The Cheerleader for?
It's young adult — teen protagonists with crossover appeal.
Find your next read by its genome
Tell Novelome one book you love — get recommendations tuned to your taste, including the ones other sites never surface.
Start free →More readalikes: Books like THE LET THEM THEORY · Books like EXTREME OWNERSHIP · Books like WINGS OF STARLIGHT · Books like DON'T BELIEVE EVERYTHING YOU THINK, EXPANDED EDITION · Books like I WILL TEACH YOU TO BE RICH, SECOND EDITION · Books like FAKE SKATING · Books like THE CREATIVE ACT · Books like IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER